"A scholarly and eminently readable... work [that] has effectively illuminated the various subjective elements of this school of theology, pointing to a religious vitality that has often gone unrecognized by critics of the Princeton theology. In so doing, the author has produced a work that is both instructive and well-written."
- David N. Murchie, Christian Scholar's Review

[Hoffecker] demonstrates quite successfully the error of modern theologians who have charged [Alexander, Hodge and Warfield] as having separated Christian piety from their systematic understanding of the Christian faith."
- Richard Klann, Concordia Journal

"Must reading for anyone interested in contemporary Christianity in America."
- Peter C. Erb, Provident Book Finder